A history of booms, busts and financial stress

The wine industry's history is a series of boom-and-bust cycles driven by export market disruptions, oversupply and changing consumer preferences — each crisis followed eventually by recovery, but not always for those who bore the cost.

1870s – 1890s: Depression and the phylloxera threat

The severe depression of the 1890s contracted demand sharply, credit dried up and many small growers could not service debts incurred during the expansion years. The simultaneous threat of phylloxera — the vine louse that had devastated France — created both a financial and existential crisis. South Australia held phylloxera at bay through quarantine, but many vineyards were abandoned or changed hands at distressed prices.

Post-WWI: Oversupply and export market collapse

Returned soldier settlement schemes expanded plantings while the British export market was disrupted by import duties and changing tastes. A wine glut in the early 1920s collapsed grape prices and forced many growers into insolvency. Government support schemes including the wine bounty provided partial relief, but the structural imbalance took years to resolve.

Post-WWII: Fortified wine surplus

Recurring surpluses in fortified wine — the dominant style of the era — as consumer tastes shifted toward table wine. Growers oriented toward fortified production found themselves stranded as the market moved, a pattern that would repeat in different forms.

The vine-pull scheme — 1980s

Oversupply so acute that governments introduced the vine-pull scheme — paying growers to remove their vines. Thousands of hectares were removed, particularly from the Riverland. For families whose land had been in viticulture for generations, it was both a financial lifeline and a profound cultural loss.

The China tariff crisis — 2020–2024

China's imposition of tariffs in late 2020 closed what had grown to represent over 40 per cent of Australian wine export value almost overnight, triggering widespread financial distress. The tariffs were lifted in March 2024 — but the market Australia is returning to is smaller, more competitive and has changed tastes. Exports to China remain less than half their 2017–18 peak.

"Cycles in the wine industry's fortunes are normal. The current cycle, Australia's fifth, involved the longest boom but now a long slump."

— Professor Kym Anderson, University of Adelaide, Independent Review of the Australian Wine Industry Crisis (2024)

The structural shift in consumer behaviour

What distinguishes the current crisis from those that came before is that the demand-side problem is structural, not cyclical. Wine consumption in Australia declined 9 per cent between 2020 and 2022 — 50 million litres in two years. Since 2019, the number of regular weekly wine drinkers has fallen by half a million despite population growth of 1.7 million. Per capita consumption is at its lowest level in decades.

The decline is most acute among younger consumers. Millennials and Generation Z are choosing RTDs, spirits and low- or no-alcohol alternatives over wine at a structural level — driven by health consciousness, lifestyle preferences and social norms that are not going to reverse. Wine's share of the alcohol market is shrinking fastest among the demographic cohorts that will define consumption for the next two decades.

−9%
Wine consumption decline 2020–2022 — 50 million litres in two years
−500k
Fewer regular weekly wine drinkers since 2019, despite 1.7m population growth
−16%
Domestic red wine sales decline 2018–19 to 2022–23 — 231m to 193m litres
Australian Wine Consumption
Total consumption & per capita (litres), 2017–2024

Sources: Wine Australia / IWSR / AIHW

The global picture compounds the domestic one. Global wine consumption reached a 64-year low in 2025 after declining a further 3.3 per cent year on year. IWSR forecasts a further billion-litre decline globally by 2028.

Red wine: the sharpest pain

Within the broader consumption decline, red wine has suffered most acutely. Domestic red wine sales fell from 231 million litres in 2018–19 to 193 million litres in 2022–23 — a decline of more than 16 per cent in four years — driven by health trends and a generational taste shift toward lighter, fresher styles: white wine, rosé, sparkling and low-alcohol alternatives.

This is particularly damaging for South Australia, whose most celebrated regions — the Barossa Valley, McLaren Vale and Coonawarra — built their reputations on exactly the varieties for which demand is contracting most rapidly: Shiraz, Cabernet Sauvignon and Grenache.

Domestic Wine Sales by Colour
Red wine vs white wine domestic sales volume (million litres)

Source: Wine Australia, Production, Sales and Inventory surveys

A cellar full of wine that no one is buying

The consequence of years of production exceeding demand is a national inventory crisis of historic proportions. As at 30 June 2025, Australian wineries held an estimated 2.06 billion litres of wine in storage — a 5 per cent increase on the prior year. Production in 2024–25 exceeded sales by approximately 52 million litres.

The bulk price for Australian red wine has collapsed from US$1.00 per litre in 2020 to US$0.36 per litre — below the cost of production for most warm inland growers.

2.06bn
Litres of wine in Australian storage as at June 2025
262m
Litres excess above current annual sales volume
US$0.36
Per litre bulk red wine price — down from US$1.00 in 2020

Where the stress is falling: South Australian regions

The financial stress is not evenly distributed. The geography of distress maps closely to variety exposure and the proportion of growers dependent on bulk and commodity wine production.

Riverland
Highest Stress

Ground zero for the current crisis. Australia's largest irrigated wine grape growing area, producing predominantly red varieties for the bulk and commodity market. Grape prices have collapsed below the cost of production. Rural Business Support has supported 227 grape-growing businesses since July 2022 — one in four growers. In 2024, some growers were offered $4,000 per hectare to exit.

Langhorne Creek
High Stress

A high-volume producing region heavily weighted toward red varieties — Cabernet Sauvignon and Shiraz — supplying large winery groups. The collapse in bulk red wine prices and winery contract reductions have placed many growers under severe financial pressure.

McLaren Vale
Significant & Worsening Stress

The Endeavour announcement strikes McLaren Vale particularly hard. Chapel Hill — one of the valley's most recognised producers — closes at the end of June. The Vinpac McLaren Vale bottling facility will follow. Smaller independent growers without their own brands or direct-to-consumer channels face a market with one fewer major buyer.

Barossa Valley
Bifurcated

A tale of two industries. Premium old-vine Grenache and heritage Shiraz commands strong prices. But commodity-end growers face the same price pressure as the Riverland, and the Krondorf Barossa vineyards — now being sold by Endeavour — add further fruit to an already oversupplied market.

Coonawarra
Red Variety Exposure

The Riddoch Coonawarra vineyards — sold by Endeavour — are the most recent addition to a market already struggling with Cabernet Sauvignon prices below the cost of production. Premium positioning supports the top end, but mid-tier and commodity producers carry material demand risk.

Pivoting is not as straightforward as it sounds

The industry's standard response to structural market shifts is to 'pivot'. The advice is easier to give than to act on, and in the current circumstances, the barriers are substantial.

Viticulture is not a fast-moving industry. A vine planted today will not produce its first commercial crop for three to four years, and will not reach its best production potential for a decade or more. For growers already under financial stress, the capital required to replant simply does not exist.

The no- and low-alcohol category is growing, but producing genuinely high-quality dealcoholised wine requires significant technology investment, and consumer willingness to pay is limited. The regions under the greatest stress — warm inland areas with irrigation-dependent viticulture — are not the regions best suited to the cool-climate whites and lighter styles the market is moving toward.

The Endeavour restructure illustrates this perfectly. Even a company with Endeavour's resources, brand assets and retail distribution network — arguably the most powerful route-to-market in Australian liquor retail — has concluded that the current economics do not support continued investment in wine production in McLaren Vale or Coonawarra. If scale and market access at that level cannot make the economics work, the pathway for smaller operators is considerably narrower.

What this means for banks with winery and viticulture exposures

For the financial institutions that have funded the wine industry's expansion, the structural contraction now underway presents a material and growing credit risk challenge. In a contracting industry, every component of the typical winery or vineyard security package faces simultaneous downward pressure.

Land values in distressed regions are already eroding. In the Riverland, some growers were offered $4,000 per hectare to exit in 2024. The addition of Endeavour's SA vineyard assets to the market — well-maintained, well-known properties — will establish price benchmarks that further compress what buyers will pay and what lenders can defensibly assume in security assessments.

Water licence entitlements are a critical and often underappreciated component of security for irrigated Riverland lending. As viticultural exits multiply, the simultaneous release of entitlements onto the market creates a correlation risk — the very scenario in which lenders most need to realise security is the scenario most likely to suppress water licence values.

Winery equipment and processing assets have limited alternative use value in a market where existing winery capacity already exceeds the volume of wine being made. The closure of Vinpac McLaren Vale will add processing equipment to an already-soft market.

Going concern value erodes rapidly when grape contracts are being cut, inventory is accumulating and the brand's market positioning is under pressure. The Endeavour announcement will accelerate the reassessment of going concern assumptions across the sector.

Proactive lender engagement — refreshing valuations, stress-testing recovery scenarios across all security components, understanding each borrower's grape contract status and inventory position, and engaging early with signs of distress — will produce materially better outcomes than waiting for the security position to deteriorate.

Pathways to survival: what winery owners can do

Not every winery or vineyard facing financial challenges is facing inevitable insolvency. The industry will consolidate, and those who survive will do so by making clear-eyed decisions about their positioning, product mix, cost base and capital structure.

Know where you stand in the market

Who is buying your wine, why, and at what price point does it genuinely compete? The current market is unforgiving of muddled positioning. Clarity of position — and the willingness to accept that the current positioning may not be sustainable — is the starting point for any credible recovery strategy.

Product mix: move toward what the market wants

The consumer is buying less red and more white, rosé, sparkling and lower-alcohol styles. Where fruit is sourced from third parties, renegotiating procurement contracts toward white and emerging varieties can begin immediately. Where the business owns warm inland red variety vineyards, the question of replanting, removal or alternative use must be confronted honestly.

Price point discipline: resist the temptation to discount

Excess inventory is better moved under secondary labels, in bulk or through private channels than by publicly discounting the primary brand. Once consumers associate a label with a lower price point, recovering premium positioning is very difficult.

Inventory management: stop making wine you cannot sell

Every litre in tank represents capital tied up and storage costs accumulating. The priority is a realistic drawdown plan — accelerated sales, bulk wine disposals, export of aged stock, or in extremis below-cost disposal that frees up capital. Making less wine by reducing the crush or releasing surplus growers from contracts is a painful but often necessary decision.

Asset rationalisation: right-size the business

Surplus tank capacity, underutilised processing equipment, non-core vineyard blocks and redundant storage facilities represent capital that could be released. Water entitlements not required for a smaller operation are separately tradeable. A managed contraction — retaining the premium blocks and the brand while selling peripheral assets — is frequently more viable than maintaining full-scale operations. Move before the Endeavour assets flood the market further.

Capital structure: address debt before it addresses you

Proactively restructuring debt on a basis that reflects current and realistic future cash flows — rather than projections anchored to a market that no longer exists — is almost always preferable to the alternative. Lenders are generally better served by a negotiated restructuring than a forced realisation in a distressed market.

Some businesses will find that an honest assessment leads to the conclusion that an orderly wind-down or sale is a better outcome than accumulating losses in hope of a recovery that may not arrive in time. Reached early and acted upon decisively, that is not a failure — it is sound commercial judgment that protects creditors, employees and owners alike.

DuncanPowell's experience in wine and viticulture

DuncanPowell has longstanding experience in the wine and viticulture sector across South Australia. We have been involved in formal and informal appointments involving growers, winemakers, wine distribution businesses and related agricultural enterprises — and we understand the particular financial, operational and human dimensions of distress in this industry.

If you are a director, grower, secured creditor or other stakeholder in a wine or viticulture business facing financial difficulty, we encourage you to seek advice early. The options available diminish significantly as financial stress deepens — and the earlier we engage, the more pathways remain open.