The aspiration of Indigenous self-determination is both legitimate and important. The organisations through which that aspiration is expressed must simultaneously honour deeply held cultural obligations and satisfy the requirements of Australian corporate law. When those two systems pull in opposite directions, the consequences can be financially serious — and for the communities that depend on these organisations, profoundly damaging.
The landscape
There are approximately 3,000 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander corporations registered under the CATSI Act, regulated by the Office of the Registrar of Indigenous Corporations (ORIC). They manage billions of dollars in government funding and commercial revenue, deliver essential community services, hold native title rights and operate enterprises from community stores to pastoral stations. They range from large, sophisticated organisations with professional governance to small remote community corporations run by volunteer boards with minimal administrative support.
What unites all of them — and distinguishes them from non-Indigenous counterparts — is the dual governance environment in which they operate: simultaneously answerable to Australian corporate law and to the cultural authority structures of their communities.
Two systems, one organisation
Western corporate governance rests on the primacy of the legal entity, fiduciary duty, formal decision-making through documented processes, and separation of personal and organisational interests. Indigenous governance systems rest on authority derived from kinship and cultural knowledge, obligation to family and community, consensus-based decision-making, and accountability expressed through cultural and relational norms.
Neither system is superior. The problem is not a deficiency in either system — it is the practical reality of an organisation that must operate within both simultaneously, and the moments when the two systems produce different answers to the same question.
Where the tension translates into perceived risk
Kinship obligations and resource allocation. In many Indigenous cultures, a person in a position of authority or resource access is expected to share that access with their family. This is a genuine and deeply held cultural obligation — not corruption in the conventional sense. But when it shapes employment decisions, procurement, cash advances or access to organisational assets, the corporate law framework characterises it as a conflict of interest or breach of fiduciary duty. Over time, these patterns accumulate into material financial stress.
Cultural authority and formal governance. Corporate law vests decision-making in the board of directors. Cultural authority flows from kinship, seniority and ceremonial knowledge — none of which map neatly onto a formal board. The result is that formal directors may lack real community authority, while those who hold genuine cultural authority may not be directors at all. Decisions that comply with the CATSI Act may lack cultural legitimacy; decisions that carry cultural authority may not comply with the Act. The gap between the two can produce paralysis, director disputes and governance breakdown.
Reporting obligations and capacity constraints. The CATSI Act's reporting requirements — AGMs, audited accounts, directors' reports — assume administrative infrastructure and professional support that many remote community organisations simply do not have. Failure to meet these obligations is the most common trigger for ORIC examination and special administration.
"In April 2025, Kalumburu Aboriginal Corporation was placed in administration after failing to provide board minutes for 13 meetings, lodge audited financial statements or hold AGMs. That same month, Binjari Community Aboriginal Corporation was wound up by the NT Supreme Court following multi-year reporting failures."
These organisations may have continued to serve their communities — but their failure to satisfy administrative requirements exposed them to regulatory intervention with serious community consequences.
Conflicts of interest in small communities. In a small community, almost every significant decision involves someone related to a director. Procurement from a family business, employment of a relative, housing allocation affecting a director's kin — these are not isolated incidents but the ordinary texture of economic life where everyone is connected. The challenge is not to eliminate these relationships, which is impossible and culturally destructive, but to develop transparent, documented processes that satisfy corporate law without being experienced as an attack on cultural obligation.
Special administration under the CATSI Act
The CATSI Act provides a unique mechanism — special administration — that allows the Registrar to appoint an external person to manage or restore a corporation's operations. Unlike mainstream insolvency, its goal is restoration, not liquidation. Special administrators work within communities over extended periods, often addressing deep governance problems while preserving essential service delivery.
But special administration is not consequence-free. It is experienced by many communities as a loss of control — another external imposition on a community that has historically had too much of that. The best outcome is a community that emerges with stronger governance and renewed capacity. The worst is a community whose trust in formal governance structures has been further eroded, making the next crisis more likely.
DuncanPowell's experience
DuncanPowell has worked alongside Indigenous corporations in the Northern Territory and South Australia for many years, through formal and informal appointments, advisory engagements and insolvency administrations. Nick Gyss has particular depth of experience, having worked in the Northern Territory for decades with Aboriginal community-controlled organisations across a wide range of economic activity.
Our experience has reinforced three principles. Patience and cultural sensitivity are not optional — they are fundamental to whether an engagement produces a good outcome or a harmful one. Communities are not passive recipients of external expertise; our role is to work alongside Indigenous knowledge and capability, not replace it. And the best outcomes arise when engagement begins early — before financial stress has deepened to the point where formal intervention is unavoidable.
A final word
The governance challenges described in this paper are not new — they have been documented for decades. What has changed is the urgency: a tightening regulatory environment, more special administrations, and communities whose essential services depend on organisations navigating these tensions successfully.
The solution is not to impose mainstream corporate governance more firmly, nor to exempt Indigenous organisations from accountability. It is to work — patiently, respectfully and with genuine expertise — at the interface of two systems of governance, both of which deserve respect.
That is work that DuncanPowell is experienced in and committed to. If you are a director, adviser, funder or community member with questions about any of the issues raised in this paper, we welcome the conversation.